It can be pretty tricky and difficult to construct a dynasty fantasy baseball team and deciding on which minor leaguers you should draft, especially if you aren’t familiar with too many minor leaguers. It is important to do your research and make sure that you are drafting the players you believe will be the best players in the future and who will be able to step in and help your fantasy team once your veteran players are no longer with you dynasty team. But minor leaguers could also be very valuable to your team even if you’re not in a dynasty league. If you are in a very deep fantasy league, drafting a minor leaguer towards the end of your draft could be very valuable for you as an owner. For instance, in my Yahoo head-to-head categories league, we have a 30 round 12 team draft, but do not have a minor league roster spot. Because the league is so deep, I always opt to draft one minor leaguer towards the end of the draft as opposed to drafting a player that will be worthless to my team, being used as a rotating roster spot that I keep filling through the waiver wire and free agent pick ups.
Now the question is, who should you draft? Most fantasy owners that I know and speak to aren’t up-to-date on the latest minor leaguers, unless their name is Bryce Harper. Many fantasy baseball owners are casual fans that follow the major leaguers, but aren’t exactly focused on the happenings in a minor league ball park near you. That’s where I come in. I am here to help you. You could go to Baseball
1 – Bryce Harper, OF (
Recommendation: Must Own in All Leagues
2 – Matt Moore, SP (Tampa Bay Rays) – Moore is already being heralded as the next great Rays prospect and is expected to hold down a spot in the starting rotation to start the 2012 season. What’s not to like about
Recommendation: Must Own in All Leagues
3 – Mike Trout, OF (
Recommendation: Must Own in All Leagues
4 – Jesus Montero, C (
Recommendation: Must Own in All Leagues
5 – Shelby Miller, SP (
Recommendation: Must Own in All Leagues
6 – Manny Machado, SS (Baltimore Orioles) – Machado’s biggest knock right now is that he doesn’t take enough pitches and strikes out too often, but remember, he just finished up his 2nd season in the minors and was only 19 years old. As he gets older, he will become a more disciplined hitter and should hit for a higher average. Machado should also bulk up and start hitting for more power. Don’t expect him up in the show for a few years, but once he gets there, he could become an all-star caliber shortstop and one of the top run producers at his position.
Recommendation: Must Own in Dynasty Leagues
7 – Jurickson Profar, SS (Texas Rangers) – Profar will be 19 years old when he starts the 2012 season, but scouts already love his baseball IQ. He has already shown pop in his bat, hitting 12 homeruns, 37 double, and 8 triples in his first full minor league season. Profar is also a theft on the bases swiping 23 bags last season. He may not hit 20+ HRs in the bigs, but he should still be able to collect a lot of extra base hits which will fill up categories in doubles, triples, XBH, and SLG. He is still about 2 seasons away (could be delayed a little longer with the Andrus extension), but he should be on everyone’s dynasty roster.
Recommendation: Must Own in Dynasty Leagues
8 – Jacob Turner, SP (
Recommendation: Must Own in Dynasty Leagues
9 – Julio Teheran, SP (Atlanta Braves) – Teheran is regarded as the best Braves pitching prospect and even got a taste of the major leagues in 2011. Unfortunately, it wasn’t all roses and sunshine. I wouldn’t worry because he was only 20 years old when he made his debut. He will strike out a lot of batters, something he has done throughout the minors, but there is one red flag; his SO:BB has declined as he has advanced through the system into AA and AAA. I’m sure that will improve, but it is something worth keeping an eye on.
Recommendation: Must Own in All Leagues
10 – Taijuan Walker, SP (
Recommendation: Must Own in Dynasty Leagues
11 – Gerrit Cole, SP (Pittsburgh Pirates) – Cole had a brief stint in the minors after the Pittsburgh Pirates selected him with the #1 overall pick in the 2011 draft. He made an impression in the minors where he struck out 16 batters in 9.6 innings. He was once a 1st round pick of the Yankees, but opted to attend UCLA instead. He should be the future ace of the Pirates, and could be up as soon as 2013.
Recommendation: Must Own in Dynasty Leagues
12 – Jameson Taillon, SP (
Recommendation: Own in Dynasty Leagues
13 – Trevor Bauer, SP (Arizona Diamondbacks) – Another UCLA product and college teammate of Gerrit Cole, Trevor Bauer only pitched in 7 games in the minors in 2011, so his numbers are from small sample sizes. The numbers don’t look great, but they don’t tell the whole story. He had two terrible outings with really inflated his numbers. The other 5 innings he was lights out, striking out 43 batters in just 29 innings. Bauer should be pitching with the DBacks in 2012.
Recommendation: Own in All Leagues
14 – Bubba Starling, OF (Kansas City Royals) – Starling was the 5th overall pick in 2012 but should have been off the board sooner, but some teams were afraid he’d opt to play football in college if he didn’t get the money he wanted in order to sign. The Royals took a chance on drafting the local product and both parties were able to work out a deal before the deadline to sign that year’s draft picks. Scouts love Starling and you can tell why they do just from watching video on him. Starling is an excellent athlete and many believe he can be a superstar, and because of that, I had to rank him here and feel that he needs to be drafted in every dynasty league.
Recommendation: Must Own in Dynasty Leagues
15 – Devin Mesoraco, C (
Season: Own in All Leagues
16 – Anthony Rendon, 3B (
Recommendation: Own in Dynasty Leagues
17 – Dylan Bundy, SP (
Recommendation: Must Own in Dynasty Leagues
18 – Danny Hultzen, SP (
Recommendation: Own in Dynasty Leagues
19 – Wil Myers, OF (
Recommendation: Must Own in Dynasty Leagues
20 – Manny Banuelos, SP (New York Yankees) – Banuelos impressed many people last year in Yankees spring training and many Yankee fans were holding out hope that he’d make the opening day roster. Unfortunately for Banuelos, the Yankees sent him down to the minors. Things didn’t get much better. His numbers continued to progressively get worse as he advanced through the system. His strikeouts-per-nine went down from 9.0 to 8.1, still good number, but a red flag. His walks-per-nine have increased at each level from 2.8 in the Rookie League and A ball, to 4.9 in AA, and 5.0 in AAA. If he can improve his control, at worst he’ll be is a #2 starter. If he doesn’t, he could end up being the next Daniel Cabrera; a player with lots of potential with high strikeout rates, but terrible control that will wear out his welcome quickly.
Recommendation: Must Own in Dynasty Leagues
21 – Jarrod Parker, SP (
Recommendation: Must Own in All Leagues
22 – Anthony Rizzo, 1B (Chicago Cubs) – Rizzo struggled while he was with the Padres last year hitting just 1 HR, driving in only 9, and finished with a .141/.281/.242 line. His time in AAA was a complete 180; hitting 34 doubles, 26 homeruns, 101 RBI, and had a .331/.404/.642 line over the course of 93 games. Rizzo has shown power throughout the minors and now that he is playing for the Cubs, Wrigley should help his power numbers. Rizzo is also expected to compete for the job to be the Cubs every day first basemen to start the year, but ultimately, I expect him to get some more seasoning in the minors to start the year.
Recommendation: Must Own in All Leagues
23 – Carlos Martinez, SP (
Recommendation: Own in Dynasty Leagues
24 – Miguel Sano, 3B (Minnesota Twins) – Still only 18 years old, Sano terrorized the Rookie league with 18 doubles, 20 HR, 59 RBI and even stole 5 bases in just 60 games. He also hit for a .292 average and slugged an impressive .637. He will be a 3B when he reaches the majors, but if he gets any bigger, he may be moved to 1B. Sano does strikeout a lot, but that shouldn’t keep you away from drafting him because he has tremendous power potential. Remember, Adam Dunn struck out a lot, but you took his 40+ HRs every year. That’s the power potential he has, but could also hit for average as well.
Recommendation: Must Own in All Dynasty Leagues
25 – Archie Bradley, SP (
Recommendation: Must Own in All Dynasty Leagues
26 – Travis d’Arnaud, C (
Recommendation: Must Own in All Leagues
27 – Tyler Skaggs, SP (
Recommendation: Own in All Leagues
28 – Francisco Lindor, SS (
Recommendation: Own in Deep Dynasty Leagues
29 – Mike Montgomery, SP (
Recommendation: Own in Deep Leagues
30 – Nolan Arenado, 3B (Colorado Rockies) – Arenado has progressively moved up the system from Rookie, to A, to A+, spending one year at each level. He has excelled at each level hitting for average and his power has improved from the result of him getting stronger which are shown by his homerun rate that has continued to climb each year. He should be an extra base machine in the bigs and could hit roughly around 20 homeruns. Sounds a lot like Todd Helton-lite, but at 3B. Maybe not as much power as Helton displayed early on his career or the average that Helton hit for, but could be a similar type of hitter. It also doesn’t hurt that he will be playing his home games in
Recommendation: Must Own in Deep Dynasty Leagues
31 – Zach Wheeler, SP (
Recommendation: Must Own in Deep Dynasty Leagues
32 – Martin Perez, SP (
Recommendation: Must Own in Dynasty Leagues
33 – Drew Pomeranz, SP (Colorado Rockies) – Pomeranz was the 5th overall pick in the 2010 draft and pitched very well in both A+ and AA in 2011, allowing only 68 hits over 101 innings. He also struck out 119 but did walk a total of 38. Pomeranz has shown good control and can locate his pitches where batters have a difficult time putting good wood on the ball. That might become more difficult as major league hitters may lay off pitches outside of the strike zone, just something to keep an eye on. He could be in the
Recommendation: Must Own in Dynasty Leagues
34 – Yonder Alonso, 1B (
Recommendation: Must Own in All Leagues
35 – Josh Bell, OF (
Recommendation: Own In Deep Dynasty Leagues
36 – Christian Yelich, OF (Miami Marlins) – Yelich has already displayed in his first 2 years in the minors that he can flat out hit, and hit for a high average. The biggest question mark is whether or not he’ll be able to hit for power which is an area that the Marlins would love coming from an OF position. Yelich just turned 20 years old in December so he still has time to put on more muscle. He did hit 15 homeruns in 122 games in A ball, so the possibility is still there. Just don’t expect 30 HR seasons.
Recommendation: Own in Deep Dynasty Leagues
37 – Brad Peacock, SP (
Recommendation: Own In Deep Leagues
38 – Zach Lee, SP (
Recommendation: Own In Deep Dynasty Leagues
39 – Mike Olt, 3B (Texas Rangers) – Olt has displayed a lot of power at both the Rookie and A+ level, but also crushed the ball in the Arizona Fall League this past off season. He won’t challenge for a batting title, but he will hit for a decent average (could see him in the .270-.280 range), and he can be counted on to collect both doubles and homeruns. Although Olt is currently blocked by Adrian Beltre, he isn’t expected to be ready before the 2013 season. If that’s the case, the Rangers will find a place for him to play.
Recommendation: Own In All Dynasty Leagues
40 – Matt Harvey, SP (New York Mets) – Harvey dominated in his stop at A+ in Port St. Lucie throwing 76 innings and recording 92 strike outs, a 2.37 ERA, and a 1.197 WHIP. He initially struggled when he was promoted to AA at
Recommendation: Own In Deep Leagues
41 – Michael Choice, OF (Oakland Athletics) – When Michael Choice reported to the minors after he was drafted in 2010, he played in 30 games and slugged 7 HRs with .964 OPS, showing right away why the A’s organization and Bill Beane drafted him. There were still, and still are, a lot of questions whether or not Choice will turn into a good every day slugger. Choice silenced some more critics in 2011 by playing in 118 games in A+, hitting 30HRs, 80RBI, 28 Doubles, walked 61 times , and showed he will not just be an all or nothing hitter by batting .285 with a .376 OBP and .542 SLG. Granted, his power is what is most attractive, but he does have a knack for striking out a lot. If Choice can hit for power like this at the major league level, which some still question, he will be a very valuable fantasy player. Although the A’s outfield gets more crowded by the day, I expect him to make his major league debut later this year.
Recommendation: Own In Deep Dynasty Leagues
42 – Arodys Vizcaino, SP/RP (Atlanta Braves) – Vizcaino sat out the 2010 season with an elbow injury but in 2011 he was completely healthy and he picked up right where he left off in 2009, and actually pitched even better. Vizcaino pitched at every level in the minors and continued to strike people out at a clip of 10.3-per-nine innings and displayed great control with a WHIP of 1.134 and walked only 2.6 between all 3 levels. Only reason Vizcaino is this low in the rankings is because there is talk of the Braves turning him into a closer or set up man. You can expect to see him sometime in 2012.
Recommendation: Own In Deep Dynasty Leagues
43 – Sonny Gray, SP (
Recommendation: Own In Deep Dynasty Leagues
44 – Gary Brown, OF (San Francisco Giants) – Brown is a speedy CF who will make things happen with his legs. After he had a full season at A+ in
Recommendation: Own In Deep Dynasty Leagues
45 – Wilin Rosario, C (Colorado Rockies) – Rosario is another backstop prospect who was on his way to becoming one of the best rated prospects after his season in 2010 which he put up .285/.342/.552 with 19HR and 52RBI in just 77 games at AA. 2011 wasn’t as pleasant. He played in 29 more games in 2011 than he did in 2010, but all his numbers were down across the board at AA again. In 2011 he hit .249/.284/.457 with 21 homeruns and 48 RBI. The biggest red flag was his .284 OBP due mostly to the fact that he walked only 19 times in 426 plate appearances. That’s alarming and is more consistent with his previous 5 years in the minors. He will hit homeruns which is what you like from your catcher, and because he is a catcher, he’s worth looking at over another fringe position prospect.
Recommendation: Own In Deep Dynasty Leagues
46 – Bryce Brentz, OF (
Recommendation: Own In Deep Dynasty Leagues
47 – Rymer Liriano, OF (
Recommendation: Own In Very Deep Dynasty Leagues
48 – Nick Castellanos, 3B (
Recommendation: Own In Very Deep Dynasty Leagues
49 – Anthony Gose, OF (
Recommendation: Own In Very Deep Dynasty Leagues
50 – Gary Sanchez, C (
Recent Articles
- The Pick Up Artist
- FantasyDaddy Daily Baseball Rankings - 5/17
- FantasyDaddy Daily Baseball Rankings - 5/16
- Fantasy Baseball: Buy And Sell-Pitchers-5/15/12
- FantasyDaddy Daily Baseball Rankings - 5/15
- Buy & Sell: Batters
- FantasyDaddy Daily Baseball Rankings - 5/14
- 2 Start Pitchers - Week of 5/14
- FantasyDaddy Daily Baseball Rankings - 5/13
- FantasyDaddy Daily Baseball Rankings - 5/12











